Fair wear and tear Queenstown: Guide for landlords and tenants

In Queenstown rentals, fair wear and tear refers to the natural decline of a rental property caused by normal everyday living. It does not include careless damage, intentional damage, or misuse.

Under New Zealand tenancy law, tenants are not responsible for normal fair wear and tear when they use the property and landlord-provided chattels normally. Tenancy Services confirms that tenants are responsible for intentional or careless damage, but not ordinary deterioration from regular use.

Understanding this difference is important at the final inspection and bond refund stage. Clear definitions, good evidence, and knowledge of legal limits can help prevent unnecessary disputes.

What counts as fair wear and tear in Queenstown rentals?

Fair wear and tear is deterioration that happens over time, even when a tenant takes reasonable care of the property. It reflects normal use, not neglect or misuse.

Common examples include:

• Carpet worn thin or flattened in high-traffic areas after years of use

• Faded paint caused by sunlight exposure

• Minor scuff marks on walls from furniture contact

• Worn hinges or loose handles from repeated use

• Oven elements or appliances wearing out after normal cooking

In Queenstown, wear and tear disputes can be more common in high-use rental properties, homes exposed to strong sun, moisture, temperature changes, or heavier seasonal use. These local conditions do not automatically damage the landlord’s responsibility, but they can affect how normal deterioration is assessed.

Fair wear and tear vs damage in a Queenstown rental property

The difference between fair wear and tear and damage depends on the cause. Fair wear and tear results from normal use over time. Damage usually results from careless, negligent, intentional, or improper use.

For example, carpet flattened by regular foot traffic is likely fair wear and tear. A large stain from spilled wine is more likely to be damaged.

Legal rules that affect liability

Several legal principles guide how responsibility is decided under New Zealand tenancy law.

The two-dollar coin guideline

Some property managers use the two-dollar coin guideline as a rough rule of thumb during inspections.

For example, a very small wall mark may sometimes be treated as ordinary use rather than damage, depending on the wider condition of the property and the evidence available.

However, this is not law and should not be treated as a deciding test. Whether something is fair wear and tear depends on the cause, age, condition, severity, and available evidence.

Evidence and bond claims

If a landlord wants to claim costs from the bond, they need evidence showing the issue is damage rather than normal deterioration.

Useful evidence may include:

• Entry and exit inspection reports

• Dated photographs

• Rent and maintenance records

• Emails or text messages

• Contractor invoices

• Notes from routine inspections

Without clear evidence, a damage claim may be harder to support.

Liability limits for careless damage

If tenants or their guests carelessly damage a rental property, they are liable for the cost of the damage up to the lower of four weeks’ rent or the landlord’s insurance excess.

This cap applies to careless damage. It does not necessarily apply to intentional damage, illegal acts, or pet-related damage beyond fair wear and tear. Landlords and tenants should check the correct rule for the type of damage involved.

Depreciation and useful life

The Tenancy Tribunal considers the age and expected lifespan of damaged items.

For example, if a carpet is ten years old and near the end of its useful life, a tenant may not be required to pay the cost of a brand-new carpet. Compensation usually reflects remaining value, not full replacement cost.

This is important because depreciation helps prevent unfair outcomes for both landlords and tenants.

What landlords need to know about fair wear and tear

For landlords, the key question is whether a cost can fairly be recovered from the tenant or the bond. This depends on whether the issue can be shown to be damage rather than normal ageing.

To support a claim, landlords should be able to show:

• The problem was caused by the tenant, their guest, or their pet

• The condition has worsened beyond expected ageing

• The repair cost is reasonable

• The claim reflects the age and condition of the item

• The issue is supported by photos, reports, or written records

If these points cannot be supported with evidence, the Tenancy Tribunal may decline the claim.

How tenants can avoid wear and tear disputes

Many disputes happen at the end of a tenancy when expectations differ. A few practical steps can reduce the risk of disagreement.

Record the Property Condition at the Start

Tenants should carefully check the property when they move in and make sure the entry inspection report is accurate.

Helpful steps include:

• Taking clear, dated photos of walls, floors, carpets, fittings, and appliances

• Noting existing damage or wear

• Raising issues with the landlord or property manager in writing

• Keeping a copy of the entry inspection report

This creates a baseline if there is a dispute later.

Take reasonable care during the tenancy

Tenants are required to take reasonable care of the property.

This includes:

• Cleaning regularly to prevent buildup or staining

• Using appliances as intended

• Avoiding actions that could cause preventable damage

• Reporting problems before they become worse

Normal use is expected, but preventable damage can lead to liability.

Report maintenance issues early

If something starts to deteriorate or break, tenants should notify the landlord or property manager as soon as possible.

Keep communication in writing where possible. Delays can sometimes make problems worse and harder to assess later.

Prepare for the final inspection

Before moving out, tenants should:

• Clean the property to a reasonable standard

• Remove rubbish and personal belongings

• Check for damage beyond normal wear

• Compare the property with the original inspection report

• Take final photos after cleaning

This helps identify issues before the final bond discussion.

Keep records of communication

If a disagreement arises, written records can help clarify what happened.

Keep copies of:

• Emails or messages with the landlord

• Inspection reports

• Photos taken during the tenancy

• Maintenance requests

• Repair updates

These may be useful if the issue goes to mediation or the Tenancy Tribunal.

What to do if there is a wear and tear dispute

Disputes commonly arise during bond refund discussions. Many can be resolved through structured communication and proper documentation.

Mediation

Mediation helps landlords and tenants talk through tenancy problems with a mediator and try to reach a workable solution. The mediator does not decide the dispute for either party.

Mediation can be quicker and less formal than a Tribunal hearing. A Tenancy Tribunal application fee may apply when applying for mediation or a Tribunal hearing.

Tenancy tribunal hearing

If mediation does not resolve the dispute, the Tenancy Tribunal can issue a legally binding decision.

The Tribunal may consider:

• Inspection reports

• Photographic evidence

• Age and depreciation of items

• Whether deterioration resulted from normal use

• Whether damage was careless, intentional, pet-related, or caused by misuse

Aratohu Tenant Advocacy can provide independent support to tenants before and during disputes.

Conclusion

Fair wear and tear in Queenstown rentals follows New Zealand tenancy law. Natural ageing from normal use is not tenant damage. Liability depends on evidence, the cause of the issue, depreciation, and the legal limits that apply under the Residential Tenancies Act 1986.

If you are unsure about your position, review official guidance from Tenancy Services or speak with a qualified property manager in Queenstown. Acting early, documenting everything, and understanding your rights can protect your time and money.

FAQs about fair wear and tear in Queenstown

---

What is considered fair wear and tear in NZ rentals?

Fair wear and tear is gradual deterioration caused by normal living. Tenants are not responsible for normal fair wear and tear when they use the property and landlord-provided chattels normally.

Can a landlord charge for repainting at the end of a tenancy?

Not for faded paint or minor scuffs caused by normal use. Charging may be justified if there is damage beyond normal wear, such as large holes, gouges, or heavy markings.

How does depreciation affect damage claims?

The Tenancy Tribunal considers the age and useful life of items. Tenants should not usually be charged full replacement cost for an old item that was already near the end of its useful life.

Who decides if something is fair wear and tear?

If both parties disagree, the Tenancy Tribunal can make a decision based on evidence and tenancy law.

Are tenants responsible for mould?

It depends on the cause. Landlords must provide a rental home that is free from mould and dampness at the start and meets healthy homes requirements. Tenants must keep the home reasonably ventilated and remove mould promptly during the tenancy.

What evidence is important in a dispute?

Entry and exit inspection reports, dated photographs, written communication, maintenance records, and invoices are useful. Clear records help show whether the issue is normal deterioration or damage.